Monday, March 17, 2014

Critique of Instructional Materials

Instructional materials are essential to an effective reading program.  The given curriculum is not always enough to reach all readers.  The teacher may need to use other materials in order to meet the needs of every student.  There are several, inexpensive ways teachers can use reading instructional materials in the classroom. 
Internet Games
            There is a plethora of internet sources that teachers have right at their fingertips.  These online games can be a fun, interactive way for students to practice reading skills.  Sometimes the students don’t even realize that they are practicing their reading skills because they are enjoying the activities.  The greatest strength for this material is that children seem to respond best to technology, so it’s great whenever you can use it in the classroom.  The only weakness is that not all schools have computers in the classroom or they may not have internet access.  In spite of that, online games can be used by all age groups and skill levels.
            The student I am tutoring, Kayla, seems to struggle with her inferencing skills.  Basically she is struggling with using her prior knowledge to understand what is happening in a story.  I found one website that will help her with this skill.  This website is free to use however, you can purchase upgrades for a minimal amount of money.  The website is full of inference riddles.  All Kayla has to do is go to the website www.philtulga.com/riddles.html and play the riddle game.  The game begins with one clue about a person, place, or thing. Each round Kayla receives another clue until she is able to guess who or what is being talked about.  The goal is to figure it out with only the first couple of clues.  Kayla had fun and enjoyed practicing her inferencing skills.

Targeted Skill Reading Worksheets
            Sometimes the word “worksheet” gets a bad rap.  However, there are some worksheets that can target specific skills.  Teachers can look on the internet for worksheets to help students with a certain skill they may need help with.  The cost of these worksheets is nothing except buying paper and ink for a printer.  Teachers can also purchase books at a teacher supply store that may have a collection of worksheets that target a certain skill.  There are worksheets available for all instructional levels and can be used in any subject of learning.  The benefit of giving worksheets is that the teacher is able to individualize for each student and it is a cost effective way to meet lots of needs at one time.  One major downfall of using worksheets is that some teachers become dependent on worksheets to do all the teaching.  Worksheets should only be used as a review or as a way to focus on a targeted skill. 
            The student I am tutoring, Kayla, and I are working on inferencing skills.  I found several targeted skills worksheets to help with inferencing skills.  There are lots of websites out there focuses on this topic but I found one in particular that I thought was very helpful.  The website I found was www.k12reader.com/subject/inference.   The particular worksheet I found was working on using our visual inferencing.  Kayla had to look at a picture of a snow and ice covered tree and answer questions about the picture.  The questions asked about what season was depicted in the picture, what animals might live in the picture and what time of day the picture was taken.  She didn’t have the stress of having to read a story but was able to concentrate on the simple picture to answer questions.  This helped her to see that we use inferencing skills all the time and not even realize it.  We talked about how these are the types of questions we should ask ourselves while we are reading.  I felt like this targeted skill worksheet was an effective way to practice how to inference.  
Graphic Organizers
            Graphic organizers are used every day in classrooms across the country.  They can be used to introduce a lesson, during a lesson, and to evaluate after a lesson. Graphic organizers are used as a visual representative of a certain aspect of a story.  They can also be used to reinforce vocabulary terms.  Teachers can get graphic organizers off the internet for free or there are books full of organizers for a small cost that teachers can copy for the class.  These can be found for a variety of ages and instructional levels. 
I think the strengths outweigh the weakness when using graphic organizers.  The only weakness I can think of is the fact that most organizers require writing skills.  This could be a problem for very young students or students with certain learning disabilities.  The greatest strength is the fact that the graphic organizer helps students to “see” what they are learning so it is really beneficial to visual learners.  They also teach organization skills to students which is something they will need throughout life.  Teachers should take advantage of graphic organizers during reading instruction.
Word Wall
            A word wall is a great asset to have in any classroom.  They can be used in a K4 room and can also be used in a high school classroom.  The purpose of a word wall is to allow vocabulary words to be visible in the classroom at all times.  This is virtually a free instructional resource.  The only cost might be the purchase of either index cards or sentence strips to write the words on.  Most teachers designate a certain wall or area of the classroom to display the words.  Because this is such an effective method, the only weakness I can think of is that there may not be enough space for a word wall in a small classroom.  There are many benefits to having a word wall in the classroom.  They are the fact that the students will always have new words in front of them; the students will have a reference when they are doing writing activities; and students will be able to practice writing the words daily. 
KWL Chart
            A KWL chart is a reading instructional tool that teachers can use during whole group or small group instruction and can be used for any age group.  The cost of a chart is minimal.  I made my own chart with cardstock and laminated it.  You can also purchase KWL charts from a teacher supply store.  The only other cost would be supplying post-it notes but they are fairly inexpensive. 
The KWL chart is used as a pre-assessment and as a post-assessment activity.  The chart can be displayed in the classroom for everyone to see.  The K stands for “what I KNOW,” the W stands for “what I WANT to know,” and the L stands for “what I LEARNED.”  When a new topic or reading story is being introduced, the teacher can give each student a few post-it notes.  The student is supposed to write something that they know about the topic on the note.  They can then share their idea with the class and post it on the chart.  This is done for each section of the KWL chart.  This could take a day, several days or even weeks.  The greatest strength of a KWL chart is that it is an interactive, easy way to assess the whole class without giving a test.  One weakness of the KWL chart is that some students may be nervous to write and then share what they wrote on the post-it note.  However, an effective teacher can help those students to overcome their fear and feel confident when sharing their ideas with the class.
I actually use the KWL chart in my own 2nd grade classroom all the time.  In my reading class, we were going to start a story about the Underground Railroad.  I wasn't sure if this was something my students knew about.  So instead of telling them some background information, I pulled out my KWL chart to assess their prior knowledge.  It turns out my hunch was right… they knew nothing about the Underground Railroad.  We then concentrated on the things they wanted to learn about the Underground Railroad, or the “W” part of the KWL chart.  As we read the story, we discovered some of our questions were answered and we moved our new knowledge to the “L” section of the chart.  It was a very effective way to help the students connect with the story they were reading.

            Teachers have access to thousands of reading instructional tools.  Some are expensive and some don’t have any cost at all.  There are some that are useful for younger students and some that are beneficial for all age groups.  I have talked about several materials that have very minimal cost and can be used for any instructional age group.  When teachers are willing to be a little creative, they can find some great material that can be used in the classroom. 

No comments:

Post a Comment